Back
5
Total Score
Reviewed by
1 scientist
7
Evidence
2
Balance
7
Clarity
Share on Twitter

Reviews

MC
Mattia Cesaro
Reviewed on 14 Jun 2025
7
Evidence
2
Balance
7
Clarity

The article is well written, explains clearly the superradiance and the Zel'dovich effect and is precise in specifying that the work has not been peer-reviewed yet. The references are also provided. However, the title is too sensationalist, the system is not a physical black hole, but only an analog system (as pointed out only at the end), and the experiment shows nothing more than the universality of such effects.

0
Thank you for reporting this comment, this will be passed on to administrators.