2 requests
ScienceDaily

Scientists discover a bizarre paradox among endangered penguins

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/11/261112230458.htm

A groundbreaking drone survey has revealed a startling split in the fate of New Zealand's endangered Erect-crested penguins. While one population has remained stable for decades, another has declined by more than 40%, apparently due to a combination of predators, worsening storms, and changing ocean conditions. Even more surprisingly, the tiny Bounty Islands support nearly as many breeding pairs as the Antipodes Islands, despite being 40 times smaller.

See all reviews for ScienceDaily
Total Score
Reviewed by 1 scientist
Evidence
Balance
Clarity

Reviews

TM
Thomas Mattern
Reviewed on 17 Nov 2026
8
Evidence
7
Balance
8
Clarity

Disclosure: I am the lead author of this study. This article reproduces the University of Otago press release, so the figures and core findings are reported accurately: drone surveys (2022–2024) show near-equal breeding populations on the Bounty (~27,800 pairs) and Antipodes Islands (~29,800 pairs), with the Bounty population stable for 25+ years and the Antipodes population down by more than 40% since 1995. Two caveats: the summary states the Antipodes decline is “apparently due to” predators, storms and ocean changes, but our study does not establish causation. These are plausible contributing factors (e.g. skua predation, landslides, differing migration routes) that remain to be tested. The “bizarre paradox” headline is also editorial; the populations simply follow divergent trajectories. The key conservation point is reported correctly: pooling both populations could suggest a less threatened status than the Antipodes decline warrants, while the Bounty stronghold may face its own pressures, e.g. from fisheries.

0
Thank you for reporting this comment, this will be passed on to administrators.