AS

Alicia Schowe

No bio provided
My ORCiD profile
Activity
Joined 19 November 2026
0 upvotes
1 review

Reviews

Is The Covid-Era Aging Spike Seen In Teens' DNA Real, Or An Artifact?

IFLScience
9
Evidence
10
Balance
9
Clarity

Disclosure: I am the first author of the study.

Overall, I think this is a thoughtful and balanced account of our findings. I particularly appreciate that the article acknowledges several important limitations of our study, which I fully agree are important when interpreting the results.

In particular, we still know relatively little about what changes in epigenetic clocks mean in adolescents. Independent replication and longer-term longitudinal studies are needed to assess their robustness, persistence, and implications for later health. As the article rightly points out, our study cannot isolate a pandemic effect without a non-pandemic comparison group.

I would like to highlight that our study did examine the role of pre-existing individual circumstances and vulnerabilities. We investigated whether characteristics such as physical health and socioeconomic status were associated with changes in epigenetic aging, and found evidence that they were. As pointed out in the article, the observed changes need to be understood in the context of the broader health and social circumstances in which individuals experienced the pandemic.

My only reservation is that the article at times presents our findings more confidently than we did in the original paper. While we observed changes in some of the epigenetic measures, our findings do not establish that these changes were caused by the pandemic. I would frame them as important observations that warrant further investigation.

0